Skip to content

AI Chatbots Accused of Violating Copyright Laws Through Plagiarism

AI chatbots, including OpenAI's ChatGPT, have been accused of violating copyright laws by reproducing copyrighted text in their responses. The News Media Alliance alleges that AI chatbots create "plagiarism stew" by paraphrasing or directly repeating copyrighted news articles.

AI chatbots, such as ChatGPT, are facing allegations of copyright infringement. The News Media Alliance (NMA) has accused these chatbots of reproducing copyrighted text in their responses and argues that they lack a fundamental understanding of the underlying content.

AI Chatbots and Copyright Violations:

  1. Plagiarism Allegations: NMA's report claims that popular AI chatbots, including ChatGPT, Google's Bard, and Microsoft's Bing, are generating responses that consist of paraphrased or directly copied text from copyrighted news articles. This practice is referred to as "plagiarism stew."
  2. Unprotectable Facts: NMA argues that these chatbots are merely "learning" unprotectable facts from copyrighted training materials, resulting in a lack of understanding of underlying concepts.
  3. Unauthorized Derivative Works: The report states that AI chatbots create unauthorized derivative works by closely paraphrasing or repeating portions of copyrighted content used during their training.

NMA's investigation found that curated data sets used for training AI chatbots contain content from news, magazines, and digital media publications up to 100 times more than generic data sets. Some of the top datasets used for training Google's Bard include content from news outlets.

The report raises concerns about the impact of AI-generated content, highlighting the risk of inaccuracies, false information, and biases in the responses generated by these chatbots.

Prominent authors, including Sarah Silverman, have filed lawsuits against OpenAI and Meta, alleging that their works were misused to train AI models without permission. They argue that AI models used illegal datasets for training, which contain copyrighted content.

AI-generated content and its potential copyright violations continue to be a topic of debate. NMA's allegations shed light on the challenges and concerns surrounding AI chatbots, plagiarism, and copyright laws.

The accusations against AI chatbots for violating copyright laws by generating responses that contain paraphrased or copied text from copyrighted sources raise important questions about the role of AI in content generation and its understanding of copyrighted material.

As AI technologies continue to evolve, the legal and ethical aspects of their usage, particularly in content generation, are crucial subjects for consideration.